Postsecondary Success Counselor - High School (Leave Replacement)
Coney Island Prep · Brooklyn, NY
Posted 22 days ago · $80,000 - 85,000
or apply directly on Coney Island Prep's site. We never take the application ourselves.
Is this posting real?
- This role has been open
- 22 days Coney Island Prep's roles stay open a median of 44 days
- Reposted
- No
- Salary listed
- Yes 90% of Coney Island Prep's roles list one
- Ghost-job risk at Coney Island Prep
- high 5 stale, 3 reposted of 10 open
- Hiring momentum
- 30 roles opened in the last 90 days ↑ up vs. the prior 90 days
- Last confirmed on the employer's board
- 2026-09-17
Measured from postings appearing on and disappearing from Coney Island Prep's own greenhouse board since 2026-08-03. Full hiring picture for Coney Island Prep.
About this role
As a Postsecondary College Counselor at Coney Island Prep, you will guide high school juniors and their families through the college search and application process, ensuring students are prepared for their post-graduation paths. You will collaborate with fellow counselors, teach CCR courses, facilitate student advisory groups, and support students with disabilities. Additionally, you will manage course logistics, maintain student records, and coordinate college counseling events.
- benefits
- 3/5
- freshness
- 4/5
- career value
- 4/5
- role clarity
- 4/5
- pay transparency
- 5/5
Scored from the posting itself — how clearly the role is described, how much it says about pay and benefits, and how recently it was listed. Not a judgement of Coney Island Prep as an employer.
What you need
- Bachelor’s degree and background in college counseling, preferably in a charter school
- Passion for education and dedication to Coney Island Prep’s mission
- Proven organizational, oral, and written communication skills
- Ability to coordinate and attend occasional afterschool, weekend events and overnight trips
- A service-oriented mindset that keeps families and students at the center of decision-making
- Interpersonal skills to foster relationships with college staff, school staff, scholars and their families
Nice to have
- Knowledge of data tracking systems such as Overgrad, Schoolrunner, Google Suite, and PowerSchool
- Multilingual proficiency; Spanish, Russian, or Cantonese preferred
What you get
- Salary range from $80,000 - 85,000
- Medical, dental, vision, and life insurance
- 403(b) retirement benefit package with match
- Paid Family Leave
- MacBook Air and access to necessary technology and resources
Worth weighing
- Temporary leave replacement position until October 2026, with employment beyond that contingent on performance and vacancies
- No specific mention of professional development opportunities beyond initial training
- The role is heavily focused on collaboration and may require managing multiple responsibilities simultaneously
Summarised from Coney Island Prep's posting. Read the full original.
Listed by Coney Island Prep on their greenhouse job board, last confirmed open on 2026-09-17. PitchMeAI is not the employer.
More roles at Coney Island Prep
- Academic Operations ManagerBrooklyn, NY
- 2026-2027 High School Leave Replacement English TeacherBrooklyn, NY
- 2026-2027 Middle School Permanent Substitute TeacherBrooklyn, NY